Page 1 of 1

"Bad Environment" is confusing

Posted: Sun Jun 24, 2018 1:29 am
by Oberlus
I find confusing the label of the gaseous metabolism population malus:

GASEOUS_LABEL
Bad Environment

Regardless of the environment (for Sly, gas giant: good, asteroids: uninhabitable, anything else: hostile), you get the gaseous malus, so why call it "bad environment"?
I suggest call it "gaseous metabolism".

Edit: or "very bad/awful population", as it is actually a -50% akin as the -25% of the bad population trait.

Re: "Bad Environment" is confusing

Posted: Sun Jun 24, 2018 3:14 am
by Dilvish
Oberlus wrote:I find confusing the label of the gaseous metabolism population malus:
GASEOUS_LABEL
Bad Environment

Regardless of the environment (for Sly, gas giant: good, asteroids: uninhabitable, anything else: hostile), you get the gaseous malus, so why call it "bad environment"?
I suggest call it "gaseous metabolism".
I apparently had somehow managed to not notice what that label actually read-- I agree that 'Bad Environment' does seem somewhat peculiar for a species' native environment. Having just checked this as part of the recent corrections to pop calcs and AI, however, I'll note that the malus only applies when actually on a Gas Giant:

Code: Select all

            scope = Source
            activation = And [
                Planet type = GasGiant
                HasTag name = "GASEOUS"
            ]
So, simply "Gaseous Metabolism" is probably not quite right either.

It could be that a suitable label might be something more specific to Gas Giants like "Crushing Gravity".

I'd suggest opening an Issue about it.

Re: "Bad Environment" is confusing

Posted: Sun Jun 24, 2018 5:16 pm
by Ophiuchus
Dilvish wrote:It could be that a suitable label might be something more specific to Gas Giants like "Crushing Gravity".
As there is no explanation component about where that crushing gravity malus is coming from, we should rather call it "Gas Giant Crushing Gravity", "Gas Giant Environment", "Gas Giant Gravity" or similar...

Re: "Bad Environment" is confusing

Posted: Sun Jun 24, 2018 5:18 pm
by Dilvish
Ophiuchus wrote:...we should rather call it "Gas Giant Crushing Gravity", "Gas Giant Environment", "Gas Giant Gravity" or similar...
Sure, I like "Gas Giant Crushing Gravity" just fine.

Re: "Bad Environment" is confusing

Posted: Sun Jun 24, 2018 5:22 pm
by Oberlus
Issue opened: #2177